Free Pick-Up & Drop-Off Service - CALL (631) 753-2211
TLC Auto & Truck Repair Service Center

230 NY-109, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Call Us Now!

Monday - Friday


Best Auto Repair Shops in Long Island 2023

Top Mechanics Long Island

Auto repair is something that any car, truck, or RV owner will inevitably have to go through at one time or another. Engine parts, brakes, and tires wear down over time, and regular maintenance is essential to keep your vehicle running smoothly.


Then there are those nightmare scenarios that no one wants to face; the big jobs that come out of nowhere and that require an honest and experienced mechanic to handle the right way.


Unfortunately, it can be harder to find a trustworthy auto repair shop than most people would like. While it would be nice to trust every mechanic you meet to do the best job for the least amount of time and money, this isn’t always the case.


Thankfully, there are honest and capable mechanics out there, provided you know where to look. We’ve gathered a list of the best auto repair shops on Long Island, NY for you here, so you’ll know who to call next time you need a helping hand in the auto repair department.

5 best auto repair shops

TLC Auto & Truck Repair Service Center

TLC Auto and Truck logo

Established by owner Peter Saitta in 1991, TLC Auto & Truck is a family owned and run auto shop built on honesty and exceptional customer care. TLC started out as a mom-and-pop gas station before expanding to a full-service shop once demand grew for Peter’s expert services.


Their exceptional talent for fixing what’s been done wrong by other mechanics is one of the many reasons their customers love them — they can be trusted to tell you the whole truth and will solve all of your mechanical issues, no matter how big or small.


TLC Auto & Truck are experienced in servicing any and all vehicles; from foreign to domestic, cars to trucks, and RVs to trailers. Their free pick up and drop off service is an added convenience for their customers, and the 24-month, 24,000-mile guarantee on all repairs offers the peace of mind that can be hard to find in the auto repair industry.


TLC’s expert auto technicians are continuously trained in new technology and practices, making sure that their customers are always receiving the most up to date service. For an experienced, honest, and efficient repair experience in Farmingdale and the surrounding areas, TLC is the one to call!



Smithtown Auto Works

Best Auto Repair Shops in Long Island 2023 1

Smithtown Auto Works has been a pillar of the Smithtown community since 1974. They serve as the dealer alternative in their area, allowing customers the luxury of fully comprehensive auto service at reasonable prices.


They pride themselves in treating their customers like family and getting people back on the road swiftly and safely is their highest priority. Their honest approach to auto repair helps their customers feel at ease and is one of the many reasons Smithtown Auto Works stands out beyond other options for auto repair.


The list of available services at Smithtown Auto Works is long, offering everything from basic maintenance to brake repair, alignment to air conditioning services, and everything in between. 5-star reviews from happy customers can be found in abundance on their website, proving that their capable technicians consistently get the job done for their loyal clientele.


Their business model is based on integrity, honesty, and effective service, and they’ve shown time and again that they’re perfectly capable of delivering a satisfactory experience. In Smithtown, this auto shop is the one that residents recommend to their neighbors and friends, and with all of the great reasons listed here it’s easy to see why!



Long Island Muscle Car Garage

long island muscle car garage

The muscle car lover is a special kind of car owner. They dote on their cars and care for them like family, which is why it’s important to find the right kind of auto shop for these beauties. If you’re a muscle car collector, you need a mechanic that’s familiar with this rare breed and that shows the muscle car the respect that it deserves.


Long Island Muscle Garage in Bohemia pride themselves on being the best place to go for lovers of “All things loud and fast,” giving their customers the peace of mind that their baby will be in trustworthy, capable hands.


Offering an extensive menu of services such as general repairs, resto-mods, engine swaps and even custom builds, Long Island Muscle Garage is truly a one stop shop for all your muscle car needs. Having the peace of mind that your baby will be treated well is paramount, and you’ll find that here.


If there’s a project that you’re working on that you need a hand with, if you’re looking for a reliable source for a complete rebuild, or even if you just need some basic maintenance and repairs — Long Island Muscle Garage are the muscle car people you’ll want to call!



Darrin’s Auto Repair

Best Auto Repair Shops in Long Island 2023 2

In East Northport, residents know the name of the most trustworthy mechanic to call, and happily recommend them to friends and neighbors when prompted. Darrin’s Auto Repair provides expert services at reasonable prices, keeping their customers happy with their honest and efficient service for the last 40 years.


Being in business for four decades means racking up some serious experience, something that’s obvious when visiting this establishment. Their customer care, efficiency, and honesty are what their customers rave about the most, which serves as proof that Darrin’s Auto Repair knows their way around — both vehicles and people.


With unique features like coupons, seasonal deals, and auto care tips on their website, it’s clear Darrin’s care about helping their customers maintain their vehicles safely, and for a reasonable price. With a service menu offering everything from alignment and brakes to transmission and heating/cooling services, there’s no issue with your foreign or domestic vehicle they can’t cure.


With a reputation that’s been built on trust over a period of 40 years in the Northport community, it’s obvious why Darrin’s is the first place to call for car and truck repair needs!



A & R Alignment & Auto Repair

Best Auto Repair Shops in Long Island 2023 3

A full-service auto shop with a philanthropic vibe, A & R Alignment & Auto Repair is a great place to call for all your auto repair needs. Their “Giving Back” program is a unique feature not found in many auto repair businesses; they support charities such as St. Jude Children’s research Hospital and Little Shelter Animal Rescue, among several other honorable causes.


This kind of generosity is a great indicator that your business is appreciated, and that you’ll be rewarded with excellent service when you trust your vehicle to the experts at A & R.


A & R takes pride in their relationship with customers, treating them with the respect and honesty they deserve. Their comprehensive list of services ensures that any vehicle, foreign or domestic, will be well cared for by their capable team of technicians.


Thanks to their continuous training on the latest advances in technology and practices, your service will always be the most up to date version possible. For repairs as simple as an oil change to the more technical jobs like clutch repairs or suspension work, A & R Alignment & Auto Repair are a smart choice to make for all of your auto repair needs in Smithtown.




When shopping for auto repair businesses, it’s not always easy to know who to trust. Thankfully, there are honest and reliable mechanics out there if you know where to find them, which is also not always easy!


The purpose of this post is to help you solve this problem; you’ll be in good hands with any of the repair shops on this list. If you’re looking for the best auto repair shops on Long Island, you’ve found five of them here.


So, whether your vehicle just needs basic maintenance or has a bigger issue that you need resolved, now you know who to call for help! You can have the confidence and peace of mind you deserve when trusting your car or truck to the mechanic of your choice, so contact one of these auto repair shops for your auto needs today!

Share this post

Auto & truck repair on Long Island, NY. 30+ Years of Experience. Free Pick-up & Drop-off Service. Call us for a free quote!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call Now Button(631) 448-3725